Madonna (Cheese Slice)

Why people love it

Charred foldable thin crust with bright sauce and a dry-jack finish. Infatuation and locals call the cheese slice a city standout; some prefer other shops for classic plain.

What people mention most

• ny slice1
• zero flop1
• crisp1
• slices beat whole pie1
• best ny-style sf1
• best vibes1
• counter service1
• ny cheese ratio1

Criticism

• larkin5
• cold slice1
• pricey1
• wait1
• dry crust1

On the menu

House cheese slice: marinara with fresh and aged mozzarella, finished with basil, olive oil, and dry jack. Their plain-cheese SKU (Marge is the more margherita-leaning build).